NLTK ships a security wrapper, nltk.pathsec.ZipFile, that is meant to confine archive extraction to trusted data roots and to block link-based escapes. When nltk.download() installs a package, the extraction write opens each member's target path without checking whether that path is a hardlink to a file located outside the data root. A local actor who can write inside a shared or predictable NLTK data root (for example ~/nltk_data, a group-writable /usr/share/nltk_data, or a shared container volume) can pre-plant an in-root hardlink at a member path that a soon-to-be-installed package will write. When the victim later runs the download, extraction truncates and overwrites the outside-root target through that hardlink. This is the same weakness class as the previously fixed downloader hardlink issue, but the fix did not reach the package-extraction write sink, so the latest published release remains exploitable through this path.
The prior fix added an st_nlink > 1 refusal to the file-open helpers (nltk.pathsec.open / _hardened_open) and routed the downloader temporary-file write through that hardened opener, so a multiply-linked inode is refused on those paths. The extraction write sink was never given the same check. On published releases, nltk.pathsec.ZipFile.extract validates member names with validate_zip_archive and then delegates to the standard library extractor, whose plain open(targetpath, "wb") opens and truncates a pre-existing hardlink. The containment guard validate_zip_archive relies on Path.resolve() and name checks; resolve() follows symlinks (so a symlinked member is correctly refused) but a hardlink has a legitimate in-root name and in-root resolved path, so it passes. No code on the extraction path performs the st_nlink fstat that the sibling open helper performs.
Affected component: nltk.pathsec (archive extraction), driven by nltk.downloader
Released sink (<= 3.10.3):...
3.10.4Exploitability
AV:LAC:LPR:LUI:NScope
S:UImpact
C:NI:HA:H7.1/CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:H/A:HFile System
Input Validation